Fake News In Biblical Archaeology

800px-Gospel_of_Jesus'_Wife
The “Gospel of Jesus’ Wife” is a credit-card sized papyrus which has been shown to be fraudulent. Photo Credit: Public Domain / Wikimedia Commons

In a world of fake news and internet hoaxes it’s important to carefully check your sources before you inadvertently spread misinformation.  The world of archaeology is no exception to sensationalistic stories and purported “discoveries” that turn out to be flat-out false.  This is especially true in the world of biblical archaeology, which has seen its fair share of fake finds.  Unfortunately, this sometimes takes in undiscerning Christians and occasionally even “experts” who are overly invested in the news.  So, to help clarify things and to put an end to the urban myths I continually hear touted by well-meaning people, here are five archaeological discoveries that are simply not true.

1) Egyptian Chariot Wheels in the Red Sea

ChariotWheel
Photo Credit: Wyatt Archaeological Research NOTE: Wyatt “Archaeological Research” does not carry out reputable “archaeological” research

This is probably the “discovery” I hear people repeat most often.  Maybe you’ve heard it to: “Archaeologists have discovered Egyptian chariot wheels and bones in the Red Sea, which proves the story of the Exodus and the crossing of the Red Sea in the Bible.”   This claim seems to have originated in 1993 through a newsletter put out by the “Wyatt Archaeological Research,”1 which sounds impressive until you learn that Ron Wyatt was not an archaeologist (he was a nurse anesthetist) and that he claims to have found almost 100 biblically-related items all within a decade, including:

-Noah’s Ark

-the fire and brimstone balls from the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah

-The tower of Babel

-The Ark of the Covenant

-The original 10 commandment tablets

-Goliath’s sword

-The site of Jesus’ crucifixion, including the blood Jesus in an “earthquake crack” beneath the crucifixion site that he claims he had analyzed and showed it only contained 24 chromosomes instead of 46.

The list of fantastical discoveries should in and of itself raise questions about any discovery Ron Wyatt claimed to have made.  This didn’t stop his “discovery” of chariot wheels spreading.  It has been repeated in articles and books and documentaries though.  In actual fact, Ron Wyatt’s work has universally debunked by respected archaeologists and scholars.  Joe Zias, the former Curator of Archaeology and Anthropology for the Israel Antiquities Authority said, “Mr. Ron Wyatt is neither an archaeologist nor has he ever carried out a legally licensed excavation in Israel or Jerusalem…We are aware of his claims which border on the absurd as they have no scientific basis whatsoever nor have they ever been published in a professional journal. They fall into the category of trash which one finds in tabloids such as the National Enquirer, Sun etc. It’s amazing that anyone would believe them.”2 Two ministers in his own denomination (Seven Day Adventist) wrote an entire book called, “Holy Relics or Revelation: Examining the claims of Ron Wyatt” to show his work was largely a hoax.3

The Egyptian chariot wheel story gained new a new life when it appeared in an online article in World News Daily, which claimed, “Egypt’s Antiquities Ministry announced this morning that a team of underwater archaeologists had discovered that remains of a large Egyptian army from the 14th century BC, at the bottom of the Gulf of Suez, 1.5 kilometers offshore from the modern city of Ras Gharib.”4  Those who were taken in by this hoax obviously didn’t read the disclaimer at the bottom of the article which read, “World News Daily Report assumes all responsibility for the satirical nature of its articles and for the fictional nature of their content.”

To be clear, no chariot wheels from the Egyptian army that drowned chasing Moses and the children of Israel as described in Exodus 14 have ever been found.

In contrast to hoaxes like this, there is good research being done by respected scholars and archaeologists that has confirmed numerous details of the biblical account of Israel in Egypt5, identified the likely Pharaoh of the Exodus6, and highlighted evidence for the actual date of the Exodus.7 8 9

 

2)  The Gospel of Jesus’ Wife

800px-Gospel_of_Jesus'_Wife
The “Gospel of Jesus’ Wife” is a credit-card sized papyrus which has been shown to be fraudulent. Photo Credit: Public Domain / Wikimedia Commons

In 2012, Harvard University professor, Karen King, announced the discovery of a papyrus that was written in Coptic (an ancient Egyptian language) that read, “Jesus said to them, ‘My wife…” and may have referred to Mary Magdalene.  King provocatively named it the “Gospel of Jesus’s Wife” and dated it to the fourth century AD, maintaining that it might have been copied from a second-century AD “gospel.”10

Almost immediately, scholars began to suspect it was a modern-day forgery, as one pointed out that the text and line breaks appeared to be copied from another papyrus that had been published in a 1924 book.  Eventually Ariel Sabar, an investigative journalist from The Atlantic did an expose that tracked town the true original owner of the papyrus, a former Egyptology student named Walter Fritz who had at one time run an art website that sold pieces that looked like ancient manuscripts.  Fritz eventually admitted to being the owner of the papyrus.  While he never admitted to forging it, he did stress that he had never once claimed the papyrus was authentic.11

Karen King eventually conceded that the papyrus is likely a forgery and that its owner had lied to her about its provenance.  Sadly, as is all too common in cases like this, the original announcement was met with great interest and picked up by news networks around the world, while the retraction generated little interest and coverage.

People interested in following the discovery of new manuscripts related to the Bible would be better off following an expert organization, such as the Center for the Study of New Testament Manuscripts at www.csntm.org or the Current Events updates at www.BibleArchaeology.org.

 

Goliath’s Skeleton – In the Bible, Goliath is the great Philistine warrior who is described as being over nine feet tall (1 Sa 17:4).  In February 2018, a news story made its way around social media proclaiming that Goliath’s skeleton had been discovered.  The sensationalistic claim went on to declare:

 “Diggers in Israel believe they’ve made a giant discovery. For they’re convinced they’ve come across Goliath’s skull! And what’s more, they say, the stone from David’s slingshot is still embedded in the forehead.”

Archaeologist Dr. Richard Martin says: “We found the skull in the Valley of Elah, in the foothills of the Judean Mountains, where David’s battle with Goliath took place. The skull is huge and clearly belongs to a man of enormous stature.”12

Screenshot (404)
Some of the photos which accompanied the fake “Goliath Skeleton” story. Photo Credit: Snopes.com

The story is essentially recycled from a 1993 article that appeared in the tabloid Weekly World News.  Some of the accompanying pictures were actually taken from a 2008 photoshop contest from the website Worth 1000, called “Archaeological Anomalies 12,” in which participants submitted pictures that were intended to “create and archaeological hoax.”  One of the pictures was an actual photograph, but it was of a sculpture done by Italian artist Gino De Domonicis called “Calamita Cosmica” (“Cosmic Magnet”), which is in the Museo Nazionale delle Arti del XXI Secolo in Rome.13

Rather than being taken in by obvious tabloid trash, there is real research being done by actual archaeologists on the Philistine people.  The recent discovery at the Philistine city of Gath of a proto-semitic inscription dating to the 10th century BC with a name that etymologically very close to Goliath, demonstrates that names like this were common at the time the Bible says they are.14  In 2016, a cemetery was excavated at the city of Ashkelon, which demonstrated that Philistine burial practices were different than their Canaanite and Israelite neighbors.15  To date, no giant skeletons have been found there.

Fake news is nothing new, and hoaxes are not unknown in the world of biblical archaeology.  There are many reputable archaeologists doing good field work in the lands of the Bible.  The work of the Associates for Biblical Research (www.BibleArchaeology.org)  is one such group whose announcements and discoveries can be trusted.  So check the source your information before your share it.

FINAL WORD:  Fake news and archaeological hoaxes are different than different interpretations of archaeological discoveries.  As the old saying goes: ask two archaeologists and you’ll get at least three opinions.  Some have estimated that real archaeology is 10% digging and 90% interpretation.  So healthy debate surrounding archaeological discoveries will always be present.  For this blog, I’ve chosen to focus on “discoveries” that were patently false.

FULL DISCLOSURE:  I am a staff member and writer for the Associates for Biblical Research.

 

ENDNOTES:

1 http://www.wyattnewsletters.com/exodus/ex05.htm

2 http://www.tentmaker.org/WAR/Zias.html

3 https://www.christiancourier.com/articles/1511-ron-wyatt-the-indiana-jones-of-the-sda-church

4 https://worldnewsdailyreport.com/red-sea-archaeologists-discover-remains-of-egyptian-army-from-the-biblical-exodus/

5 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2008/09/24/Israel-in-Egypt.aspx

6 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2010/02/04/Amenhotep-II-and-the-Historicity-of-the-Exodus-Pharaoh.aspx

7 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2009/10/19/Recent-Research-on-the-Date-and-Setting-of-the-Exodus.aspx

8 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2011/11/11/New-Evidence-Supporting-the-Early-(Biblical)-Date-of-the-Exodus-and-Conquest.aspx

9 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2012/01/05/The-Duration-of-the-Israelite-Sojourn-In-Egypt.aspx

10 https://www.livescience.com/51954-gospel-of-jesus-wife-origins.html

11 https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/07/the-unbelievable-tale-of-jesus-wife/485573/

12 https://www.dailyvoice.co.za/news/goliath-found-13044902

13 https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/is-this-goliath-skeleton-real/

14 https://gath.wordpress.com/2006/02/16/comment-on-the-news-item-in-bar-on-the-goliath-inscription/

15 http://www.biblearchaeology.org/post/2016/07/11/Philistine-Cemetery-Unearthed-in-Ashkelon.aspx

 

4 comments

  1. Regarding point 1) Who’d be so dumb to rely on respected archeologists and scholars, most of which are driven by pride? Disparaging such discoveries is mainly the result of envy (as usual). Anyone doing some snorkelling at Nuweiba Beach can see the chariot wheels for themselves, and for those with a PhD: a wheel is usually round.

    • Hi Jake, thanks for taking the time to read and interact with my blog. For my own part, I would rather trust a trained archaeologist than a nurse-anesthetist who has made wild claims about what he “discovered,” especially when respected, trained archaeologists and scholars have convincingly demonstrated that Ron Wyatt made fraudulent claims (You can read about some here: https://www.christiancourier.com/articles/1511-ron-wyatt-the-indiana-jones-of-the-sda-church). Your comment that archaeologists and scholars who dispute Ron’s findings are “dumb” and “driven by pride” seems to be presumptuous and paints them all with the same brush.

      • If I trusted respected scholars and archaeologists, I’d still believe in molecule to man evolution (and you can hardly get lower than that).

        Do me a favour and visit Noah’s Ark National Park, Sodom, Gomorrah, etc., collect some sulfur balls and then we’ll take it from there.

      • For me, the difference here is that evangelical Christian archaeologists and scholars whom I trust have pointed out the inconsistencies and fraudulent claims that Ron Wyatt made with no credible response from Ron’s organization. I’d recommend the work of the Associates for Biblical Research, a group of evangelical archaeologists and scholars committed to demonstrating the reliability of Scripture through their research (biblearchaeology.org). They’ve got numerous articles on the location of Noah’s Ark, Sodom and Gomorrah, etc.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s